Learning to Live with Absence

"Absence can make you realize how much of what we cling to is excess."

Last weekend, I got rid of a bookshelf. Yep — we’ve gotten far enough into our decluttering adventure to start getting rid of furniture! I was excited. It’s the first big thing we’ve let go of.

But when I moved the shelf out of its spot and into the “get rid of” pile, I was taken aback. The wall looked…well, naked!

I didn’t like the hole. I felt something was missing, and it made me uncomfortable. Something had shifted. Something had changed. There was less in the room, and it felt empty.

Half of me wanted to put the shelf back, fill it up again. I didn’t. And now, after learning to live with its absence for a time, I’m adjusting.

In fact, I’m better than adjusting. I’m loving the empty space — and looking around the room to figure out what else I can get rid of!

Introducing Absence

This shelf adventure got me thinking about absence. Of physical stuff, yes, but of more than that.

I think we’re generally uncomfortable with absence. It suggests lack, inadequacy, incompleteness. Something is missing, and that’s assumed to be a negative thing. We work hard to fill in or cover up the absences in our lives.

But I can’t cover up the fact that a wall in my home is now empty. I see it every day. I’ve had to face it. And it’s forced me to face some other absences, too.

Absence can make you realize how much of what we cling to is excess.

Shedding Old Identities

When we get rid of our physical stuff, there’s a deeper clearing that inevitably happens, whether we want it to or not. Along with letting go of a thing, you also shed the way you defined yourself through that object.

For instance? The shelf I just cleared held all my baking books. I used to adore baking. I would tell people, “I’m a baker, not a cook.” Because of that identity, I didn’t do much in the way of cooking — but hardly a day went by that I didn’t bake up a new treat.

I’ve since learned through trial and error that the ingredients of baking don’t agree with my body. I kept my baking books for a long time. They felt like a part of me. Then one day, I realized — having them there on my shelves only made me sad. I was happy with how I’m eating now and with how much better I feel…until I looked at my shelf and saw all the things I couldn’t eat anymore.

So, one by one, I’ve let those books go. As I do so, I’m letting go of the image of myself as a baker. It’s a little sad, but at the same time, it opens up all kinds of new possibilities.

I’m no longer a baker trying to adapt to an ever more restricted set of raw materials. I’m a person exploring new kinds of food, experimenting to see what’s both delicious and best for my body. I even brewed up a batch of my own kombucha with the guidance of a new friend — something I’d never have tried a year ago.

And none of that probably would have happened without the absence of an outdated identity.

It’s opened my space, my energy, and my attention up to exploring new things I’m actually interested in. And it feels amazing. I’m giving myself permission to let go of an old dream and embrace a new, maybe still unknown one. I feel lighter, more agile, more excited.

When you’re trying to live as vastly different versions of yourself, it’s nearly impossible to be comfortable in your own skin or feel confident about anything. You have to bring your identities into alignment, and that means dropping the ones that are outdated or inaccurate. Let go of even one, and you’ll begin to feel less scattered, more centered, more complete.

Here’s My Challenge to You:

Take a look around your life. See if you can find one object that belongs to a former identity, a way of seeing yourself that you’re ready to let go of. It could be a piece of clothing, a photo or letter, a book, a knick-knack, a remnant from an old hobby, anything at all.

Once you’ve found it, figure out what it says about you, what it’s forcing you to hold onto.

Now let it go. Toss, recycle, donate, give away, sell that item. Get it out of your life — and with it, that outdated version of yourself.

How does t make you feel?

Some other posts you might enjoy:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I recently got rid of a collection of shot glasses from all over the world. I've been carting it around with me for over 17 years. A few months ago I was cleaning out a closet I found a big and but couldn't remember what was inside. It was the shot glasses. since I no longer drink shots (I was a wild child back in the day) and haven't displayed knick-knacks in years, these glasses don't really hold much value to me. They're not who I am now. So I recycled them. And I don't miss them a bit. 

Now I'm mulling over old yearbooks that I haven't opened in who knows how long. It's a process.

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

@Kimberly Awesome! It's amazing what meaning we attach to things that have outgrown their usefulness and that don't really reflect who we are anymore, isn't it? I still have my yearbooks, but I shredded my old diaries not too long ago.

deniseurena 72 pts

Love this idea.  I'm pretty good at letting go of physical objects that aren't a part of my identity anymore, but I think this can apply to labels we put on ourselves as well.

For example, I still introduce myself as a pastry chef, I've worked in that field for 12+ years, but I'm not doing it right NOW.  And I'm embarking on something completely different, so introducing myself with that label is like introducing my old self to people over and over again and they miss out on who I am and what I'm working on right NOW.  It's been hard to let go of that label because I've worked so hard to earn it.  

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

deniseurena I can imagine it would be really tough to let go of something you've worked so hard for. I've never had something I've poured so much time and effort into, but my experience with shorter-term identities has made me realize how tenacious they can be. For me, I've been experimenting with letting go of labels and identities by letting go of the physical manifestations of them -- but I hope to work up to being able to identify and let go of the same things without the physical component.

sarahemily 77 pts

Oh yes... I feel like I am deeply familiar with the desire to fill up the empty spaces right now, more in the metaphorical sense than the literal one. When I was getting rid of furniture it felt soooooo good, but I think I was ready to let go of having an apartment anchoring me to a particular place, so the letting go of furniture was more symbolic of another letting go that I had already accepted. Congrats on the progress!!

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

sarahemily Interesting! I like that -- like your mind was ready for the stuff (physical and not) to go and just reveled in it. I wonder, then, if the urge to declutter often ends up being a sign that one needs to let go of something?

ethanwaldman 129 pts

I recently gave up a fleece that I've had since college. When I bought it, it was something that I enjoyed wearing and did wear quite frequently. But now, it has gotten pretty ratty and I kept it around purely for sentimental reasons. I finally got rid of it last week and haven't thought about it until.. well.. now! 

In my own de-cluttering, I've also found that it takes time getting used to absence. It's so easy to fill a blank space with more stuff-- but once you learn to live with it, you become familiar and accustomed to the absence! 

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

ethanwaldman I have some of that sentimental-type clothing. Half of it doesn't even fit me anymore, and yet I take it with me every time I move. Gotta work on that. Your fleece story gives me a little inspiration to tackle my closet.

You must be doing some serious decluttering, with the tiny house plans! What's that process like?

ethanwaldman 129 pts

remadebyhand I did a lot of decluttering when I first started thinking about the Tiny House. Then I put a lot of stuff in storage, so it's all out of site right now. I've gotten myself down to a pretty small amount of clothing that's out of storage and available. But I will have to go through all that stuff once the house is ready and decide whether it still fits with my life or not.. 

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

ethanwaldman I can imagine something like that would really change your relationship with stuff. I'd be interested to hear about where it takes you :)

joeyjoejoe 94 pts

To steal a line from James Brown, "I feel nice. Like sugar and spice." Every time I remove some form of chaos from my life - clutter included - it just feels freakin' awesome. I know what you're saying about the bare walls, shelves, and other parts of our physical environment we've been conditioned to fill up with stuff. Even before I was a minimalist in the modern sense, I always had an appreciation for and drive to make my walls and other vertical surfaces (e.g. computer monitors) free of everything. 

Back in my corporate gig, people would say to me at work, "Why don't you have any pictures of your family up on your walls?", as if it meant I didn't love them because I wasn't physically displaying them in front of me all the time. We can have a lot of love and find a ton of meaning without the presence of physical objects everywhere. I'm glad more and more people are realizing that every day.

And the best part? You can still wear the baker label without all those cook books and all the old stuff you used to bake. I can share some amazing coconut flour and almond flour baking recipes with you whenever you want.

My latest conversation: Forums | | Enlightened Resource ManagementEnlightened Resource Management

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

joeyjoejoe I've always been the opposite, Joel! I've always covered my surfaces with stuff. Picture frames and candles and knick-knacks everywhere, piles in all the corners and on all the surfaces. I'm glad I've "seen the light" somehow because man, does it feel good to clear all this stuff away!

I do love my photographs. I've hung most of them on the wall at this point -- I don't see myself cutting too far back on what I hang on my walls, because all the pieces there are meaningful to me and make me smile. My feeling is, if an object is useful and/or makes me feel joy when I see/use it, it can stay. For now :)

As for recipes -- yes PLEASE! Whatever you've got, send it over. That'd be awesome. Talk about remaking...I'll remake myself from unhealthy baker into healthy baker!

Shanna Mann 202 pts

Aww, that's a little sad about baking. I actually thought to myself today, "When Christmas gets here, I'll take baking round to all the neighbors." And then I realize I hadn't baked since my birthday. Nobody eats sweets in this house, so when I bake I have to eat it all myself! And I know myself well enough to know that I bake for the appreciation of others. 

I've been good about shedding former identities, but what I find with food is that I eat it for how I think it will make me feel, and then it never measures up. So I've all but stopped eating ice cream, and I've added juice and noodles to the list. I have to consciously remind myself: I know they *seem* like a treat, but you'll get a sugar headache, and that's not a treat, is it?" So what I'm really suffering from is the absence of treats. I've got to figure out how to replace them!

Shanna Mann 202 pts

Karen J I have been enjoying them, but they have such a short season. And I've already learned that canned fruit doesn't measure up. I've been mainly consoling myself with exotic coffees and cheap wine :)

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

Shanna Mann Yeah, the baking thing is sad. Christmas will be really tough, with my family baking up a storm! Interesting that food sticks around for you. I think it's been easier for me to let go of because I have physical reactions to some of it. Look into Paleo or whole grain treats -- I have some tasty recipes! They take a little getting used to, but they don't make you feel like crap :)

Jo - Young Ambitions 11 pts

This was really interesting to read. I was just talking to someone about how maybe the idea I have in my head of who I am might not have kept up with how I've changed over the last year. I've become more independent, I have a whole different philosophy, completely different ambitions and I'm not following anyone else around - I'm leading myself. But in my head I'm shy, quiet, a sheep and I latch on to other people for guidance. Wow, I'm a totally different person.

One day I'd like to live in a tiny house on wheels and love the idea of decluttering. I had been viewing decluttering as a massive task I would need to spend loads of time on someday but I've realised it would be easier to just get rid of one thing each day or week and ease my way into a calmer environment.

I've always kept my old phones. Even though I don't have the chargers for them and can't turn them on, I've kept them because I know they're full of messages which I'd kept deliberately. These texts were from people I thought were amazing and texts full of compliments and 'I love yous'. They made me feel special. I don't look at them anymore but getting rid of them would probably mean recognising that those relationships don't exist anymore, which is sad. But getting rid of them might also make me feel free and confident: I don't need that validation anymore and I have carried on without those people. I will have to keep thinking about this!

Wow - you really got me to think there, Erin. Thank you.

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

Jo Young Ambitions YES! I have those same two versions of myself. Or at least, really similar. The one in my head is so loud it keeps me from hearing the one outside -- and sometimes even overshadows it.

I've been amazed by how much getting rid of at least one thing a day has added up to. (I ended up getting rid of more than one thing on a fair number of days, because I felt like getting rid of one book from a stack of 40 every day was cheating! But I only HAD to get rid of one, so I didn't feel pressured.) At the three-month mark, we'd gotten rid of almost 600 things, based on the photos we're taking. There was a ton more that never got photographed. It's crazy how the momentum can build!

Ha, I had my old phones, too. I just got rid of them as part of this decluttering project. I can see why you want to hang onto them -- so many good messages. I found a bunch of notes and papers from high school, elementary school, even before that, some from people I don't even remember. Yet I still had trouble letting go because it's like these things were proof that mysterious someone cared about me at some point. Having now gotten rid of them, I can say: I feel free, because I got rid of the physical clutter. I feel free to move forward. But I haven't forgotten that throughout my life, I've had people who cared about me. Recycling those notes and cards didn't erase that at all.

I'm glad you got to think about this stuff a bit. I've been finding it a tough but really rewarding process :)

amitsonawane 11 pts

Oh no, not the bookshelf! ;) Perhaps you can create something (painting, poster, artifact, etc) and hang it up where the bookshelf once stood? That way you're filling the absence of yr old identity with your present one. Just my 2-cents, not sure if that agrees with the whole minimalism agenda. Good post, Erin! 

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

amitsonawane Don't worry. We still have pleeeeenty of bookshelves, stuffed full of books! That's an interesting idea about how to fill in the space. I like the blank wall...but updating it would be a neat idea, too. I haven't really declared any specifically minimalist intentions, so I'm free to do whatever :) Hmm...

KimThirion 22 pts

This makes me uncomfortable just thinking about it. Guess that's a sign.

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

sunkissedbutrfly I'm starting to look at discomfort and fear as signs I need to explore something further. Totally counterintuitive...and yet, so far it's been working :)