Are You Rowing with Both Your Oars?

"Motivation is a boat rowed by the oars of heart and mind." (remadebyhand.com)

photo courtesy of FreeWine

I’ve been working on a project for the past couple of months.

(No, I won’t tell you what it is. Yes, you’ll find out soon. Unless you’re a newsletter subscriber, in which case you already know — shh!)

Working on my secret project been teaching me about motivation. I’ve been discovering how much more easily I learn a new skill when I’m working on something I care about.

I mean, that makes sense, right? But knowing something intellectually and experiencing it personally and with awareness are two completely different animals.

A Tale of Two Projects

Over the summer, I started a free intro-level programming class online. I’ve been interested in exploring programming languages for a while, so I thought I’d give it a try. The material was interesting, the course was nicely structured and presented, and the homework was challenging without being impossible. And yet, from the beginning, I had to force myself to sit and watch the video lessons. I fidgeted as the minutes dragged by. I started skipping homework problems. Eventually, halfway through, I quit.

Yesterday, I opened up a new piece of software for the very first time. Playing around with it interests me, but more than that, I need to learn to use it in order to finish this project of mine. With no one to teach me and no course to follow, I jumped in and started messing with things, searching for tips online when I got stuck and occasionally swearing in frustration. Much later, I looked around and realized several hours had passed. I hadn’t even noticed the time flying by. I’d been so absorbed in the learning process I’d totally forgotten to do a couple of other things I had to get done. And I’d been thoroughly enjoying myself.

So what’s the difference? I want to learn both the programming language and the software program. In the former case, someone else had already laid out a course of study for me, so logic suggests I should have preferred this nice smooth path to hacking through the jungle on my own.

And yet, the opposite was true. Huh?

The Motivation Formula

The more I pay attention to what I enjoy learning and what I don’t, the more I realize I have to have a personally significant reason for diving into a particular skill. It’s not enough to have an intellectual interest. There has to be an emotional desire driving my learning.

So for me, I think my motivation formula looks something like this:

Motivation = What + How + Why

What I’ll be learning and how I’ll be learning it are obviously important — I wouldn’t get very far without either. They can come from my logical, intellectual side. But why I’m doing it is what keeps me moving forward. That has to come from my heart. A mentally-imposed why is no why at all.

Rowing with Both Oars

I think we often forget about the the why, the heart. It’s more emotional, more tempermental, less trustworthy than the steady, rational mind. It’s harder to plan in advance. So we discount it and rely on our minds instead.

But it’s really hard for me to find that deep, inspiring, energizing motivation that makes learning so amazingly fun and productive without the spark that comes from the heart. I have to be invested in what I’m doing. I have to see why I’m learning what I’m learning in the first place. I have to know how it applies to something I care about. When I can make that connection, I’m floored by the difference.

Heart and mind are like the two oars that row our motivational boat — drop one, and you’ll just go in unproductive circles. But if you can get them in sync, you’ll go far. (You were wondering where that strange post title tied in, weren’t you?)

I’ve written about how to find your why elsewhere, so I won’t repeat myself here. But I think we (myself included) need to actually do it more often. It’s easy to get stuck in someone else’s why: coworkers, parents, friends, teachers, society. When you opt for another person’s why, you don’t have to think. You can just drift along.

But if you want to live a life that’s meaningful to you, that why is crucial for anything you undertake. It puts what you’re working toward in your own terms instead of someone else’s. It makes what you’re doing yours, gives you a stake in whether you succeed or fail. And that is a very powerful thing.

I’m Curious:

What’s your motivation formula? Does having a why driving your actions make a difference for you?

Some other posts you might enjoy:

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Lori Stalter 16 pts

As long as I'm learning something I'm interested in, I enjoy learning it on my own or by traditional methods.  But on my own is definitely more spontaneous and I get a deeper sense of accomplishment when I figure something out on my own through research and trial and error...like figuring out how to get my featured images to show in a theme that didn't support them!  Woohoo!  :-D

I need a why for sure.  And that why can't be money.  I learned that a long time ago.  I don't do well if it's somebody else's why either.  It has to be my own.  I think the only exception is doing things for my kids while they're still in my care.  I've often taken on their passions as if they were my own so they'd have a support person who understands what they're working on or trying to achieve for themselves.  But that special mother/child bond doesn't work for anything else - not even a significant other.  At least not for me.

contrarywise_ 5 pts

I'm exactly the same, when left to my own devises if it is something I want to discover I will spend hours learning. It is a lot harder to concentrate when I don't feel that burst of interest.

I think this is just the way we learn, we can be self motivated learners when we get to set our own goals, other learners require more structure. I am a theoretical learner, I need ideas and theories and problems to solve, a lot of my friends are more practical and can sit listening to lectures on anything. 

CWBusiness 20 pts

There is a big difference between something that is interesting if you had all the time in the world and things you really, really want to do or learn.  We sometimes don't realize the difference.  Like buying a course or book and then not doing it or reading it.  We thought we wanted to do it, but then we aren't that fussed.  I'm like you.  If I really want to learn something, I can get lost in it for hours.  I find this with business - If I want to be able to do something I am happy to learn and figure it out.  But if I have to or should - forget it.  If I have to force it, it's just not going to happen.  Or not happen well.....

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

CWBusiness I have so many of those books/courses/etc! Part of my year of letting go of stuff has been clearing out some of those old "interests" ( and the potential identities tied to them) to make room for what I really want to do. I'm like that with business as well. It's hard for me to do the parts I don't like so much, but really easy to work on the others!

ethanwaldman 129 pts

Erin- I agree completely about your motivation formula. For me, my fourth element is to remove distractions. I have so much trouble focusing and staying focused on things that are important to me when there are other things calling at my attention!

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

ethanwaldman Ooh, yeah, distractions. I have more trouble with those when I'm *not* totally absorbed in my task, I think because I'm looking for other things to do. When I'm absorbed in what I'm doing, I often end up forgetting to do other things, or not wanting to do them because I'd rather be doing this other thing! That state is pretty elusive for me, though, so most of the time I do lots of distraction-fighting.

deniseurena 72 pts

Definitely!  Your formula sounds like mine for sure. The why for me is all about how much the project captivates my interest and how it will serve other people. There are projects that I love and I get lost in them, but I'll lose interest over time if I don't see how it's going to benefit other people. Also, my motivation is greatly tied to being challenged. I live for the puzzle, for finding interesting and new connections, and finding alternative and unique solutions.

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

deniseurena Oh, I like the part about serving others. That's something I'm realizing is important to me, though I'd not thought of it as being linked to my motivation. As for puzzles, I find I like them -- as long as they're not so hard I get frustrated and give up! ;)

joeyjoejoe 93 pts

Hey Erin,

First off, I only have one paddle. That's because I use a kayak and don't believe in inefficient row boats any more. :)

My motivation formula contains the same components as yours except the order is Why, How, What. It sounds like that's your order too even if the formula in this article doesn't show that. I mean, sure. I could throw in things like When and Where to the formula but they're only relevant once the first three items are addressed. It's a progression. If I can't get past Why, why bother with anything else?

By the way, love the picture, love the headline, and love the intrigue with the newsletter. If I wasn't already part of your newsletter community, I'd totally take that bait (fishing/boat/water pun, get it?). Other people definitely should too. :)

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

joeyjoejoe Kayak! That is perfect! Talk about having the two ends in sync...hard not to be with a setup like that!

Yes, well, since the order of the components doesn't matter with addition (mmm, math skills ;) I didn't put too much thought into the order of mine. But yes, I think they why is the first piece, in most cases. I might roll when and where into what -- I think they often fit there.

Thanks for all the positive feedback! And nice, extending the metaphor... :)

sarahemily 77 pts

Hooray! Yes. I have realized that I've been struggling in doing certain things lately because I'm not paying enough attention to the "why." And also why I think it will be much easier to learn a new language if I am actually in a non-English speaking country. And probably a million other things, but I'm just going to say yay for this realization! Thanks as always for the bing!

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

sarahemily Yes, needing to learn a language to get by and being surrounded by so many resources would, I think, be really motivating! (Plans to pursue that soon??) I'm noticing whenever I start to lose steam, it's because I've lost touch with why I'm doing what I'm doing. Hope reconnecting with your whys helps :)

Shanna Mann 202 pts

What an AMAZING metaphor!! I think I'll have to steal it. It perfectly illustrates what I'm always saying about how agonizing and slow it is to try and make progress if your heart and mind are not united.

I always find I learn (and remember) so much better if I'm working on a project. Learning just to learn... not really that efficient. Learning to achieve a desired result = yours for life.

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

Shanna Mann Woot! The Metaphor Maven likes my metaphor! Go for it, it's all yours. It's ridiculous how long it's taken me to figure this stuff out. How many hours have I thrown at projects and pursuits my heart wasn't in, only to have them fizzle out? Approximately a zillion, give or take.

KimThirion 22 pts

I noticed this... things I want to do or learn, but either keep getting put to the side, or I give up on. I used to just consider myself a procrastinator. But eventually I realized that it wasn't procrastination - that I was choosing certain things over others because I was more interested in them. I've tried to learn Spanish for years. I took two years of it in high school and I remember the majority of the vocabulary... but not the sentence structure and conjugations. My fiance is Puerto Rican - so I have a good reason now to learn the language, but I haven't. I know I want to, but since he speaks English just fine (and we don't visit his parents often), I haven' felt the need to start practicing it again. 

I'd say a why is pretty essential for me -- even if the why boils down to "because I want to", which it does occasionally.

So for me, I'd say my formula  would be: Motivation = Need + Why(sometimes separate from a need) +Interest

remadebyhand 211 pts moderator

KimThirion Yes! Ooh, very much so. I do the same thing, "procrastinating" for whatever reason. But I bet it's the same as with you -- the things I put off are the things I just don't feel that drive to pursue. And yeah, "because I want to" is totally valid. If something unnameable is pulling you to do something, that's legit. Thanks for sharing your formula. I really like the distinction between need and why -- I will have to think about that more for myself :)